Loaded with butterscotch chips and a rich, deep-caramel dough, this cookie owes its dense, fudgy bite to a not-so-secret weapon: JELL-O Butterscotch Pudding folded straight into the batter. It’s your fave comfort food, remixed into cookie format.
Gluten-Free Milk Bar® Pie
Restocking soon! For 18 years, the internet has been obsessed with our Milk Bar Pie, and now…
Get the details Select options






















Reviews
There are no reviews yet.