All the Pie
Two pies, zero debate. The gooey, buttery Milk Bar Pie that started it all meets its seasonal…
Get the details Add to cartTwo pies, zero debate. The gooey, buttery Milk Bar Pie that started it all meets its seasonal…
Get the details Add to cartDessert for the whole feast, handled. Maple Cookie Butter Cake, Pumpkin Milk Bar Pie, and a dozen…
Get the details Add to cartTwelve Cider Donut Truffles, six of your favorite Milk Bar cookies, zero decisions to make — this…
Get the details Add to cartCover every fall craving with our Maple Cookie Butter Cake and the classic Milk Bar Pie. One…
Get the details Add to cartMaple Cookie Butter Cake meets a dozen Cider Donut Truffles for the ultimate fall lineup. Perfect for…
Get the details Add to cartFall’s two heaviest hitters, one box. Maple Cookie Butter Cake brings brown sugar layers and cookie butter…
Get the details Add to cartIf we believed in popularity contests, these fan favorites would win. The best-selling Birthday Cake and Assorted…
Get the details Add to cartA pie for the table and a dozen truffles for anyone who can’t wait for dessert. Pumpkin…
Get the details Add to cartCall it, 5 times the chocolate, with this super indulgent combo of our new, over the top…
Get the details Add to cartA birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters for an all-out celebration. This bundle includes…
Get the details Add to cartA birthday-flavored no-brainer fit for any kind of celebration. 1 Birthday Cake + 1 dozen B'Day Truffles…
Get the details Add to cartEveryone needs a little encouragement sometimes, and we’ve found that dessert does a pretty amazing job. A…
Get the details Add to cartWhatever the fall party calls for, this combo's got it covered. A dozen Cider Donut Truffles and…
Get the details Add to cartWe doubled down on our truffle game for this megapack of bite-sized beauties. One dozen classic B'Day…
Get the details Add to cartMore room at the table, more pie on it. Our iconic Milk Bar Pie is finally gluten…
Get the details Add to cartLoading your cart…